Vacation Rental Search

Featured Properties

Off-Island Vacation Homes

Exclusive AMI Collection

1-2 Bedroom Rentals

3-4 Bedroom Rentals

5-6 Bedroom Rentals

7+ Bedroom Rentals

Dog Friendly Rentals

Best Pool Homes

Luxury Beachfront Rentals

Water Access Rentals

Monthly Rentals

Longboat Key Rentals

Preferred Partners

View All Rental Properties

Luxury Anna Maria Island Rentals

Experience Your Vacation Like a True Local with AMI Locals

Choose from over 300 top-notch Anna Maria Island rentals, including prime locations on the island and nearby areas. Our homes undergo thorough inspections, and with local 24/7 guest services, personalized recommendations, and continuous communication, we ensure a seamless booking and stay experience. Whether you seek lavish luxury or a laid-back beach vibe, our diverse properties promise the perfect beach vacation. AMI Locals also offers comprehensive property management services, maintaining and managing homes with a commitment to enhancing the Anna Maria Island community for visitors and residents.

Featured Properties

Ariel's by the Sea

203 75th St, Unit A (East)

3
2
6

Bay Breezes at Bayside Bungalow

201 S Bay Blvd, Unit #1

2
1
6

Bay Vista at Bayside Bungalow

201 S Bay Blvd, Unit #5

3
2
6

Bayside Cutie at Bayside Bungalow

201 S Bay Blvd, Unit #2

1
1
4

Blissful Bay at Bayside Bungalow

201 S Bay Blvd, Unit #4

3
2
6

Malibu Beach

8
7
16

Villa #2 Shrimp

3605 Gulf Dr, Unit #2

0
1
2

Villa #3 Seahorse

3605 Gulf Dr, Unit #3

1
1
4

Villa #4 Sand Dollar

3605 Gulf Dr, Unit #4

1
1
4

Villa #5 Seashell

3605 Gulf Dr, Unit #5

1
1
4

Changes in Latitude 403

396 Aruba Cir, Unit #403

3
3
7

Sea You Soon

6250 Holmes Blvd, Unit #55

3
2 Full, 1 Half
6

Sandy Pointe

3607 E Bay Dr, Unit #105

2
2
4

Water's Edge 205

5808 Gulf Dr, Unit #205

1
1 Full, 1 Half
4

Starfish Cove, A

7802 Palm Dr, Unit A

2
1
4

Starfish Cove, B

7802 Palm Dr, Unit B

2
1
4

Coconuts Gulf View #117

100 73rd St, Unit #117

2
2
6

Sea Glass Harbor

239 S Harbor Dr

4
4 Full, 1 Half
8

Coconuts Gulf View #118

100 73rd St, Unit #118

2
2
6

Tahiti Bay

215 Magnolia Ave

5
4
12

Sea Gal

7
7 Full, 1 Half
15

Stuck on 'cation

1810 80th St NW

3
2 Full, 1 Half
8

Sun Kiss

102 7th St S, Unit B

1
1
2

Happy Ours

102 Magnolia Ave

5
3
8

St. Barth

2104 Avenue B, Unit B

2
2
4

St. John

2106 Avenue B, Unit A

2
2
6

St. Maarten

2106 Avenue B, Unit B

2
2
4

St. Thomas

2104 Avenue B, Unit A

2
2
6

Riverview Retreat

4307 Riverview Blvd

4
2
10

Bikini So Tiny

1
1
4

Bay Cruiser

10307 Kingfisher Rd W

3
2
6

Coastal Hideaway

3
2
6

Three Little Birds

720 37th St W

4
3
10

Sol Cool

2610 11th Ave W

2
2
6

Here Comes The Sun

392 Aruba Circle #402

3
3
6

Laughing Mermaid

2208 3rd Ave W

3
3
7

On the Flip Side

2210 Avenue A

7
7 Full, 1 Half
16

Shore To Escape at Hunter's Point

4353 Marina View Way

3
2 Full, 1 Half
7

Salt and Sand at Hunter's Point

4332 Saltwater Pearl Way

2
2 Full, 1 Half
6

Angler's Cove at Hunter's Point

4329 Marina View Way

3
2 Full, 1 Half
10

Bella Vista

2806 Avenue C

3
2
6

Whim Sea

376 Aruba Circle Unit 401

2
2
5

Moku

7147 La Lenaire Dr

5
5 Full, 1 Half
15

Casa Cortez at Hunter's Point

4223 Marina View Way

3
2 Full, 1 Half
6

A Piece of Paradise

720 Fontana Lane

3
2
9

Only Sunsets at Hunter's Point

4309 Marina View Way

3
2 Full, 1 Half
8

Luxe Island Escape

421 Alamanda Rd

4
4 Full, 1 Half
8

The Lilly Pad

8320 43rd Avenue Terrace W

3
2
6

Grandview

511 Bayview Drive

4
4
8

Tropic Like It's Hot

6
6 Full, 2 Half
14

Hook Wine and Sinker

5
5 Full, 1 Half
12

Infinite Views

6
5 Full, 1 Half
12

Seven Palms Beach House

770 Russell St.

3
3
6

Gulf Breeze Getaway

350 North Shore Rd

3
3
8

Bring the Heat

1915 38th St W

4
2
8

What's up Dock

10125 Manatee Ave West Unit D3

2
2
4

Casa Rosa

404 21st Place N

4
3
10

Guest Reviews

Beautiful and comfortable home perfectly located. You can walk across the street to the Bay beach and an easy 10 minute walk to Bean Point beach. Also an easy walk to Pine Ave. The pool and hot tub was great under the shade of the house & out of the blistering Florida sun. also allowed the kids to swim if it was raining. Water views from every balcony. Great option on a beautiful island.
~ Gina S.

Upcoming Event

Bishop After Hours Presents: 90s VS 2000s Laser Light Double Feature

The Bishop Museum of Science and Nature, 201 10th St W, Bradenton, FL 34205

08/08/2024 - 08/08/2024

6:00pm - 10:00pm