Tarpon Lookout

Beautiful and luxurious home right on the beach!

Cherish H. - Posted: 10/17/2026

The star of this property is the location and beach access. The views from the balconies were unmatched. We loved being able to walk out the door to the water and beach. The living space is large and we never felt cramped. We also liked that there were plenty of dishes for the size of groups this property would host. The pool was serviced/cleaned multiple times during our stay which was great and the property management company was quick to help if needed. Property provided a couple of beach chairs, tent, wagon, lots of beach towels.The property could definitely use a deep clean: not all cookware was clean (blender needed cleaning), drying rack was pretty gross, some mold on bathroom caulk, coffee table dirty where people have put their feet up etc.As with some other properties, some of the finishing touches could use work such as making sure there are full sized baking sheets so you can cook for large groups and having decent towels.Great spot for families. Could be a bit tight for couples as some of the rooms didn’t have room for large suitcases near beds. We were able to fit a mini crib in one of the rooms, a full sized pack and play would have been tight if not in the primary. Overall we really enjoyed our stay and would consider staying again.

Paige R. - Posted: 10/16/2026

We’re so glad you enjoyed the incredible beach access, balcony views, and spacious living areas at Tarpon Lookout by AMI Accommodations, Paige. It’s wonderful to know the home worked well for your family, and we’re happy our team was there when you needed assistance. We appreciate your thoughtful suggestions regarding the kitchen supplies, towels, and deeper cleaning details. We’ve shared these comments with our team for review as we continue working to make each stay as comfortable as possible. We’d love to welcome you back for another beachfront getaway!

AMI Locals staff

Nice location and very comfortable home

Juette T. - Posted: 9/24/2026

A comfortable home in a great location makes settling into island time pretty easy, Juette! We’re glad Tarpon Lookout by AMI Accommodations was a good fit for your stay and gave you a relaxing place to enjoy Anna Maria Island. We appreciate you choosing to stay with us and hope you’ll come back for another beach getaway!

AMI Locals staff

We enjoyed our stay at this beautiful property. The location was great and the sunset views were incredible. We hope to return and stay again soon!

Jennifer L. - Posted: 7/11/2026

Sunsets have a way of making every day on the island feel a little more special, Jennifer. We're so glad Tarpon Lookout by AMI Accommodations gave you the perfect place to enjoy those incredible evening views. It's wonderful to hear the home and its location made your stay such a memorable one. Thank you for choosing to stay with us, and we hope to welcome you back to Tarpon Lookout for many more unforgettable sunsets on Anna Maria Island!

AMI Locals staff

Ashley O. - Posted: 7/4/2026

If you are on the fence…book it! What a wonderful place to spend a week! Nothing is better than having coffee and hearing the waves.

Renee C. - Posted: 6/21/2026

Thank you for the wonderful review, Renee! Nothing beats starting the day with a cup of coffee while listening to the waves roll in. We're so glad Tarpon Lookout by AMI Accommodations provided the perfect setting for a relaxing week on the island. One of our favorite things about this home is how easy it is to slow down, soak in the coastal views, and enjoy those peaceful moments that make an AMI vacation so special. Your recommendation means so much to us, and we’d love to welcome you back to Tarpon Lookout for another unforgettable island escape!

AMI Locals staff

Verified traveler - Posted: 5/18/2026

Amazing home. Extremely clean and comfortable

Deborah - Posted: 5/3/2026

Love hearing that—thank you, Deborah! We’re so glad Tarpon Lookout by AMI Accommodations felt clean, comfortable, and just right for your stay. We’d be happy to welcome you back anytime for another easy island getaway!

AMI Locals staff

Great home and breath taking views!

Erika D. - Posted: 3/30/2026

That’s what we love to hear—thank you, Erika! We’re so glad Tarpon Lookout by AMI Accommodations impressed you with both the home and those breathtaking views. It’s a pretty special spot to soak it all in. We’d love to have you back anytime for another laid-back island getaway!

AMI Locals staff

Beautiful setting

Susan Z. - Posted: 3/27/2026

Short and sweet—we love it, Susan! Tarpon Lookout by AMI Accommodations really does have a beautiful setting which is perfect for soaking in those easy island moments. We’d love to welcome you back anytime for another laid-back getaway!

AMI Locals staff

this is a premium place to stay. if you’re looking at it, book it!

Eric H. - Posted: 3/21/2026

Now that’s what we love to hear—thank you, Eric! We’re so glad Tarpon Lookout by AMI Accommodations made such a great impression. It really is a special spot for a comfortable, easy island stay. We appreciate the recommendation and would love to have you back anytime!

AMI Locals staff

Todd S. - Posted: 3/9/2026

Beautiful house with the perfect location!

Tracy R. - Posted: 2/28/2026

Tracy was a pleasure to host.

AMI Locals staff

Our family has rented over 30 beachfront homes. The true test of a vacation rental home is when the weather is less than ideal. Unfortunately during our stay the temperature ranged from the 20’s in the evenings to 60 degrees on one afternoon, not typical for a Florida beach holiday. In this situation it is essential that the rental home makes the stay fun and relaxing despite the weather. Luckily Tarpon Lookout provided comfortable accommodations for our entire family. First the location is ideal for those that want to have direct beach access. The gulf is just a few steps from the home, as well as the private pool and spa, you are literally on the beach. At the same time there is access to the Kokonut Tiki Bar, restaurants and shopping nearby without an overly commercial feel to the neighborhood. The house is well appointed, maintained and decorated. There is some wear and tear but not to an uncomfortable degree. We had nine adults and we had the space to spread out when we wanted and congregate for family game nights as well. The AMI team was very interested in making sure we had everything we needed without being intrusive. There was a maintenance issue with a window in the master bedroom and the staff did all they could given the circumstance to work towards its repair and keeping us informed. The only observations we have regarding the stay would be nit picking. It is unusual to be concerned about how to deal with cold weather. It would have been nice to have had extra blankets for the cold evenings but the furnace did a good job keeping us warm enough. A large cast iron skillet would have been nice for a larger group. Over all we would definitely stay here again !!

Edward - Posted: 2/1/2026

House was beautiful. Location was awesome!

Debra C. - Posted: 1/17/2026

Hi, Debra, thank you for the kind words! We’re so glad you enjoyed your stay at Anna Maria Island Accommodations at Tarpon Lookout. A beautiful home paired with an awesome location makes for a great island getaway. Thank you for choosing to stay with us, and we’d love to welcome you back to Anna Maria Island for another relaxing visit soon!!

AMI Locals staff

Great location and communication. Beautiful sunsets and clean house.

Brad L. - Posted: 1/17/2026

Hi, Brad, thank you for staying with Anna Maria Island Accommodations at Tarpon Lookout! We’re so glad you enjoyed the great location, clear communication, and a clean home. Those beautiful sunsets really are something special on Anna Maria Island. We’d love to welcome you back for another memorable stay!!

AMI Locals staff

Wonderful house and perfect spot for our family vacation.

valerie h. - Posted: 12/17/2025

Hi, Valerie, thank you for staying with Anna Maria Island Accommodations at Tarpon Lookout! We’re so happy to hear the home was a perfect fit for your family vacation. It’s a great spot for making island memories, and we’d love to welcome you back for another Anna Maria Island getaway!!

AMI Locals staff

Absolutely beautiful home. Five lovely bedrooms, each with a bathroom and the great room/kitchen was so comfortable and lovely with beautiful views of the Gulf.

catherine s. - Posted: 11/18/2025

Thank you for choosing us for your recent stay! Every review and every star you give us makes a huge difference to our success. If you enjoyed your stay, we'd love your 5-star review! We hope to host you again in the future!

AMI Locals staff

Joan B. - Posted: 9/27/2025

The property was very nice. The kitchen was supplied better than any kitchen that we have ever rented. They were ready for large groups staying there. 2 very small complaints. Only 1 or 2 of the tvs worked and there are about 10 tvs on the premises. There were issues with the cable box. Don't expect the hot tub to be hot. Other than these 2 issues, again they were very small, the property was exceptional.

Lisa S. - Posted: 9/23/2025

Thank you for the thoughtful review, David! We’re so glad you found the property well-supplied and perfect for hosting a larger group. We appreciate you sharing the notes about the TVs and hot tub, our team will take a closer look. Happy to hear the home was still exceptional overall, and we’d love to welcome you back with Anna Maria Island Accommodations!!

AMI Locals staff

This was the ideal vacation rental home for our large family! The 5 bedrooms, each with King beds and en-suite bathrooms, met our needs perfectly. The home was clean and well appointed. The proximity to the Gulf was great with our young grandchildren. We had an issue with the elevator on the 3rd day and the response from the management company was good. The 3rd floor balcony is the perfect place to watch the sunset or to read a book. The only suggestion we have to improve this rental is to increase the amount of silverware in the kitchen (we ran out after each meal) and to put a dining table and chairs on the 3rd floor balcony instead of the existing high barstools that aren't very comfortable to sit in (and there's no table to go with the barstools). Overall, beautiful and comfortable home!

Karen - Posted: 8/16/2025

Anonymous - Posted: 9/2/2024

It's a great house in a great location... I highly recommend it. Parking for two vehicles and one in the garage is all there is; getting out of the driveway can be tricky but not a huge issue. Highly recommend! Excellent communication by the management company!!

Shelly L. - Posted: 9/2/2024

Thank you so much for your kind review! We’re thrilled to hear that you enjoyed the house and its great location. It’s wonderful that you had a positive experience with the communication from our management team as well. We appreciate your note about the parking situation, and we’ll definitely keep that in mind for future guests. We hope to welcome you back for another stay soon!

AMI Locals staff

Great spot!

Eugenie K. - Posted: 8/17/2024

Thank you for your review!

AMI Locals staff

Anonymous - Posted: 8/17/2024

We had a great family reunion and loved the property.

Al T. - Posted: 6/16/2024

Anonymous - Posted: 6/16/2024

Spacious, clean house, fairly modern amenities. Third story porch was the highlight. Direct view of the dolphin in the morning and beautiful sunsets in the evening. Host extremely responsive, respectful, and thorough throughout all stages of the stay…pre, during, and checkout. Would definitely return and recommend for families or groups.

John R. - Posted: 5/5/2024

John, thank you for your glowing review! We're thrilled to hear that you found our house spacious, clean, and equipped with modern amenities. It's wonderful to know that the third-story porch provided such memorable experiences, from dolphin sightings in the morning to beautiful sunsets in the evening. We're pleased that our team was extremely responsive, respectful, and thorough, ensuring a seamless experience from start to finish. We appreciate your recommendation and look forward to welcoming you back for another fantastic stay in the future! If you have any further comments or questions, please feel free to let us know.

AMI Locals staff

Anonymous - Posted: 5/5/2024

Anonymous - Posted: 4/4/2024

A really nice, modern, house on the beach. We probably should have chosen a different week than march break to go, but that's on us! We did have a few issues upon arrival- the elevator wasn't working, and took a couple of days to get sorted- at 30+ stairs to the kitchen and master bedroom, luggage and groceries weren't much of a treat. Dishwasher was jammed so full of dirty water, and the ice machine didn't work. But, full points to the AMI property management, everything was handled as quickly as possible, the maintenance staff that came were all great and they were all extremely caring and attentive to solving the issues. So 5 stars was going to be tough to award, until we left a stereo speaker behind...and they were again, so attentive, and so quick to retrieve it and send it back to us that they deserve the 5.

Richard V. - Posted: 4/4/2024

Anonymous - Posted: 3/19/2024

Great Island .. great house, right on the beach. Even better than the pics. Like other reviews said, the house is not particularly well stocked with kitchen stuff, but there's a great Publix about a mile away so it was not at all a problem. Location and quality of the house are both 5-star.

Steven M. - Posted: 3/19/2024

Steven, thank you for your wonderful review! We're thrilled to hear that you enjoyed your stay on the island and found the house to be even better than expected, with its prime beachfront location. We appreciate your feedback regarding the kitchen supplies and are glad to hear that it didn't pose a significant issue for you. It's great to know that the nearby Publix provided convenient access to anything you needed. We're delighted that both the location and quality of the house earned a 5-star rating from you. We hope to have the pleasure of hosting you again in the future for another fantastic stay!

AMI Locals staff

Tarpon Lookout was special! The home was properly represented-lovely, spacious, bright and cheerful! Tarpon Lookout accommodated our three families with children comfortably.
The location was perfect with dramatic ocean views! This three story home even had a very convenient elevator.
We did cite some deferred maintenance items with AMI which were addressed.
In summary, this home will host your family well!
Richard O'Neill Jr

Richard - Posted: 9/30/2023

Thank you for taking the time to share your wonderful experience with us, Richard. We are glad you enjoyed the home and convenient location. You were terrific guests, and we hope to welcome you back soon!

AMI Locals staff

We just loved the location the home was beautiful We all had a fantastic time Love it !!!

PHILIP B. - Posted: 5/7/2023

Thank you for allowing us to host you, Philip. We are glad you enjoyed your stay and hope to welcome you back again soon!

AMI Locals staff

Very nice property, highly recommend

Robert H. - Posted: 4/5/2023

Thank you for taking the time to share your experience with us, Robert. We are glad you enjoyed your stay and hope to host you again soon!

AMI Locals staff

This was our all time favorite the all the properties we have rented over the past several years. Our group of friends really enjoyed Tarpon Lookout, it met all of our needs. Beautiful home, tastefully decorated, with a great walkout directly onto the beach. Beautiful sunsets. Our rented golf cart got us everywhere on the island. Everyone agreed we would rent the property again on a future trip. Can't wait to come back!

Julie B. - Posted: 11/12/2022

Julie, we are glad you and your friends enjoyed the home and its fantastic location. We can't wait to host you again!

AMI Locals staff

I have rented family vacation homes for the last 10 years. This was the BEST. Cleanest house and pool area. TV's in every room and bathrooms. Pool/Hot tub great (once we located the controls hidden behind a privacy drape) Minor issue handled within hrs. Lots of beach equipment too.

Pat F. - Posted: 8/3/2022

Pat, thank you for taking the time to share your experience with us. We are happy to hear you enjoyed your stay, and we hope to host you again soon!

AMI Locals staff

We had a great time. Property was spectacular. Management group that manages the property did a very good job. Communication was great. We will definitely be back Wade VK - Michigan

wade v. - Posted: 3/5/2022

We had a group of 5 couples and this property was a perfect fit It has 5 king beds with their own bathrooms which is extremely hard to find. The property was beautiful and so was the beach. We will be back.

Ann N. - Posted: 12/13/2021

I rented this home for a week long vacation before Thanksgiving and it exceeded my expectations. It's very spacious and and situated right on the beach. Great walks, sunsets and views all week long were a great way to head into the holidays. My only suggestion is to add a few more kitchen bowls and platters. The home is so nice that we didn't even want to leave for dinner.

Julie D. - Posted: 11/29/2021

Julie, thank you for your recent stay here on the island. WE love hearing how the home and all the amenities were well enjoyed and most importantly you all had a great vacation. The majestic views are really postcard perfect! Thank you for the suggestion of more kitchenware is needed! You were truly a pleasure to host and we look forward to your return.

AMI Locals staff

House was amazing. Slept 8 adults with room left. Had a great stay with no problems. Exactly as described.

Greg S. - Posted: 11/24/2021

Thank you Greg for you and your group staying at Tarpon Lookout. We are thrilled your Thanksgiving Holiday was a great stay. We welcome you back anytime.

AMI Locals staff

The home was beautiful, the pool and beach were great. The management company was helpful and responsive. The house was lacking beach umbrellas but we rented them and that wasn’t a big deal. We (4 couples) all enjoyed our stay. I would recommend this property for sure.

Susan S. - Posted: 11/3/2021

Easy-great property

glynda R. - Posted: 7/22/2021

We visited with our whole family, ages 3 months to 63 years. It was perfect! House was just as described, very clean, nice open floor plan and everything you need. Nice pool and hot tub, beach just steps away, great view, it had it all. We had a lovely time.

Donna G. - Posted: 7/7/2021

Donna, Thank you for your kind words on Tarpon Lookout. This luxury home really does provide for a great time, we are glad you found this to be true. We will be looking forward to your return on AMI. Regards, Anna Maria Island Accommodations Team

AMI Locals staff

This Property was the perfect house for our family get away. Spacious living space with 5 bedroom, each with king beds and their own bathrooms. The balconies looking at the beach and seeing sunsets every night were breathtaking. We loved that we were right on the beach so the kids could play in the sand or ocean and also having a private pool & hot tub. The rental company was very fast in responding and correcting any issues we had which weren’t many. The toilet had a little issue which they came immediately and fixed. The dryer wasn’t drying as it should and they fixed it the same day we called. The elevator was great to have when needing groceries up to the top floor or if you were too tired to walk up the stairs. We loved the beachy decor! We would definitely love to rent this property again! This property would also be perfect for a couples - friends vacation. We loved everything about this property and it was definitely worth the money. We didn’t want to leave!

Diane S. - Posted: 5/19/2021

House was just want we wanted. Good location. Well kept. Rental agency did everything they were supposed to. Would come back.

Richard L. - Posted: 4/5/2021

We had a fantastic week! It is so rare to find a rental home that has everything you need, and is comfortable for everyone...we were all very happy here! The house is MUCH bigger than described (or imagined). My only suggestion for the management is to install some soft, yellow light bulbs at least in the lamps...everytime you turned on a light it was the harshest, white light - really bright and glaring (my husband is telling me not to write that b/c I'm the only person in the world who cares about such things?!) Perhaps! Some house specific instructions would be helpful, too - like how to use the elevator and raise and lower the blinds in the kitchen. It took us awhile to figure that out!

Lindsey R. - Posted: 3/20/2021

This house is amazing !!! Great location and beautifully decorated. We will be back!!

Mark M. - Posted: 1/3/2021

Mark, Thank you so very much for your kind review on Tarpon Lookout! Hearing the waves crash and seeing the beautiful white sand from that close is absolutely incredible, we are glad that you found joy in it. We are delighted that you enjoyed the interior design, every part makes this home a true work of art. We couldn't be happier that you were able to make memories by spending your holiday with us, in Tarpon Lookout, and we will be glad to see you back!

AMI Locals staff

Right on the beach !! Had a great time

Richard A. - Posted: 12/20/2020

Richard, Thank you for your review on Tarpon Lookout! We are so glad to hear that you enjoyed your vacation in this property, and will be glad to see you back soon.

AMI Locals staff

This property was great for our family of 4, (Almost 2 year old and 5 year old) + grandpa. The elevator was a lifesaver, just the perfect addition in this home with all of the stairs. Steps away from the beautiful beach, amazing pool area with a great size pool, and the tv was a nice touch. Stores and shops were right down the road and convenient to get to, we rented a golf cart and took that to run out. Was not crowded even with the inns and such surrounding the property. Weather was perfect. Worth every penny and we hope to come back!

Tim B. - Posted: 11/12/2020

This house was beautiful and the layout was perfect for a family beach getaway during Covid. I loved that the kitchen, family room, and barbecue was on the third floor because we spent a lot of time cooking and in that living space and it was very nice to be able to enjoy the view of the beach without even having to go to the beach. The kitchen was well stocked with plates, cups, and kitchen utensils. The beach was so close and perfect for those with small kids that can’t spend the full day at the beach. The elevator was perfect as the house does have a lot of stairs. The only negative we found was that the patio furniture on the third floor was lacking. The table top seemed to have broken and they replaced it with loose wood tiles that were a hazard. Since the third floor is where we spent most of our time, I think they would benefit from moving the second floor furniture up to the third floor as it is much nicer. Also, the house is surrounded by small Inn’s so on the weekend, the beach did get very full. However during the weekdays it was fairly empty. Overall we love the house and would consider returning again next year.

Monica T. - Posted: 8/27/2020

Thank you for your feedback about Tarpon Lookout. We agree that the layout of the home with the Living room, kitchen and dining on the top floor is ideal. We’ll consider switching around the patio furniture. We are always looking for ways to make our homes for comfortable and enjoyable so we’ll certain work with the home owners and make suggestions. There is a new outdoor table top on order! Thank you for staying with us and we hope you visit Anna Maria Island and Tarpon Lookout again!

AMI Locals staff

Beautiful luxurious beach front property with breath taking views. The house is spacious and tastefully decorated. Loved that each room has a king size bed and bathroom. We loved spending time on the balcony each morning sipping our coffee while enjoying the spectacular views of the ocean. A wonderful place for a family to make beautiful memories.

Rolando H. - Posted: 8/23/2020

Thank you for the great review Rolando! We are so glad to hear that you had a great time at Tarpon Lookout and made many memories. We look forward to hopefully having you stay with us again soon.

AMI Locals staff

Great location, house is beautiful!

Stephanie S. - Posted: 7/19/2020

Thank you Stephanie! We are so excited to hear that you loved the house! Let us know when your ready to come back!

AMI Locals staff

Location right on the beach!!! The house was immaculate and well stocked with kitchen essentials and linens. Easy walking to local eats/bars. Responsive management company. Would stay here again in a heartbeat!

lisa c. - Posted: 3/29/2020

Beautiful sunsets.

Suzanne A. - Posted: 1/19/2020