My Island Paradise

We were very comfortable here. The house seemed to be newly updated and the host was very responsive to questions.

Dianne - Posted: 2/28/2026

So glad to hear you were comfortable during your stay, Dianne! My Island Paradise by AMI Locals really does have that fresh, updated feel, and we’re happy our team could be there to help whenever questions came up. Thanks again for staying with us and we’d love to welcome you back for another island getaway!

AMI Locals staff

Great location, very clean and perfect set up for us and our adult children. Less than 1 mile walk to Pine Street area with shops and restaurants and trolly system very good. Appreciated beach wagon and chairs and just a 3-5 minute walk to the beach.

Marilyn - Posted: 2/23/2026

This sounds like the perfect island setup—love it, Marilyn! So glad My Island Paradise by AMI Locals was a great fit for you and your adult kids. Easy walk to Pine, quick beach access, and that trolley convenience really makes it simple to explore. And we’re happy the beach wagon and chairs came in handy, those little extras make beach days even better. We’d love to have you all back for another round of sunshine and island fun!

AMI Locals staff

We really liked the location, maybe 500-feet to walk to the beach. AMI is great for beach access, and the location of this house is nice as it has no traffic noise, is not too far from shops/restaurants, and also close to the beach.
We felt like the house was well cleaned, better than many rentals. We liked the tables and furnishings, not opulent, but nothing cheap or breakable.
The space was as-advertised with beds and such, and our mattress was actually comfortable (better than most rentals).
We stayed the week after Christmas and through New Years, so obviously a colder time of year, but our only disappointment was the pool heater did not work (breaker tripped frequently, but even when working did not raise it even a single degree and the pool was simply too cold to use, in the low 60*F range). The sun did not heat it up either due to nice tropical landscaping (palms). Probably an expensive fix, but would be fine in the warmer months.

Matt - Posted: 1/3/2026

Hi there, Matt! Thank you for your thoughtful feedback on your stay at My Island Paradise! We're thrilled to hear you loved the prime location, just a hop to the beach, with no traffic noise and are so glad you found the house clean and comfy during your holiday stay. We're sorry to hear about the pool heater, that's definitely something we’ll look into to keep things warm for future guests. We appreciate your insights and hope to welcome you back with AMI Locals soon!

AMI Locals staff

The home was clean, nicely updated, the furniture was comfortable and was well stocked. The private heated pool was great for a quick dip and to sit around at night. It was a quick stroll to the beautiful beach. There was plenty of room for my husband and I. The bedrooms were a bit on the small side but adequate. I would recommend more beach chairs. There were only two and for larger groups more would be better. Thank you for sharing your home.

Tricia - Posted: 8/11/2025

Hi, Tricia, thank you so much for your detailed and thoughtful review of our home. We're thrilled to hear that you and your husband had an enjoyable stay and that our home met your needs. We're glad the private heated pool and how close the property was to the beach came in use for you and your family. We appreciate you taking the time to share your experience, and we look forward to welcoming you back in the future with us at AMI Locals. We are always running amazing deals for our island! Thank you, AMI Locals

AMI Locals staff

We just returned from our stay and had a great trip. The house was exactly as described and pictured. Fantastic location less than a block from the beach. Unfortunately the pool was really to warm to use unless you used it as a hot tub 😂 but I guess that can’t be helped as it’s shallow and gets hot from the summer sun. We did sneak a swim in one evening after it rained as it cooled down enough to be enjoyable. We noticed the fan in one bedroom wasn’t working and texted AMI about it. They responded immediately and sent over the nicest maintenance guy to fix it. He was great and accommodating. They were really prompt and made sure we had everything we needed. I’d rent from them again for sure! My only suggestion for the house would be that it needs some rugs and a small vacuum or stick vac. The whole house is tile and hardwood and there was ALWAYS sand no matter what or how much we swept. Felt gross if you were walking barefoot and you’d track sand into your bed. Rugs would definitely help- at least at the doors and by each bed. A small stick vac would make it easier to clean up the sand than a broom. The furnishings and decorations were nice and the house was in great condition. The bedrooms are pretty small but you’re not spending time in those much so it wasn’t that big of a deal. It was great for us and we are happy with our stay and experience. Thank you AMI Locals!

Kelly G. - Posted: 7/16/2022

Thank you so much for staying with us, Kelly. We appreciate your lovely review and are glad to know the service you received from AMI Locals was prompt and friendly. Thank you, too, for your vacuum suggestion it is always good to hear a guest perspective. We hope you'll return in the future, you were wonderful guests.

AMI Locals staff

We enjoyed our week at My Island Paradise. Our family has been vacationing at Anna Maria Island for many years and we were blessed this year with good weather and the calm ocean. The house worked well for our family of adults, location was good with a short walk to the beach, shops and restaurants. If we were to have any complaints, the kitchenware could use some updating. We cooked most of our meals and our eggs stuck to the pans every morning, some of the pots did it have matching lids and it was difficult to blend fruit in the blender for smoothies. We didn’t use the pool much as the sun heated it up during the day and it was to hot to sit in. Overall, we had a great time this year and will definitely be returning to this beautiful island.

irina y. - Posted: 6/18/2022

Thank you for staying with us, Irina! We're happy to hear you enjoyed your vacation, and thank you for the note about the kitchen items so we can correct. Hope to host you again in the future!

AMI Locals staff

Convenient and well located. We had everything we could need for our stay and more. Recommend.

Alexandr - Posted: 5/21/2022

The property was as advertised. Close to the trolley and beach. Prompt response to issues we had with A/C and a ceiling fan that wasn’t working. Beds were comfortable. I would definitely stay here again.

Judy - Posted: 5/7/2022

An attractive, well-outfitted house, ideal for a family, in a great location for both the beach and bay and convenient to the trolley if you don't have a car. The pool was always warm, which was great, as it seemed to be quite shady in late Dec. Don't miss the sunsets on the beach just minutes away. The island is beautiful and offers a perfect spot for a break.

Leslie - Posted: 1/4/2022

The villa had all of the amenities for cooking, beaching it, relaxing and sleeping! We cooked most of our meals in and we had all the utensils and cookery needed. We had 3 beach chairs, pool noodles, beach towels and a beach cart. The beds were comfortable and the pool was clean and comfortable temp. We will be back!

Laura - Posted: 9/19/2021

Great location whether walking to the beach or using the free trolley!

Caitlin H. - Posted: 9/7/2021

This property was so amazing and convenient to shopping and the beach. We had everything we needed inside and out and the pool was fantastic and the perfect temp morning noon and night. Would highly recommend a stay at this location. Will definitely look to book this property again in the future.

Josh D. - Posted: 8/24/2021

Josh, Thank you for choosing your island getaway with us. We're thrilled to hear you enjoyed the pool and beach as much as we do. We look forward to your next adventure with us.

AMI Locals staff

Perfect house and location for our family of 4! Plenty to keep our 2 kids occupied and close enough to haul everything to the beach.

Rob - Posted: 6/11/2021

Thank you so much for staying with us Rob. We love hearing fromour guests and hope that you will allow us to host you once again on your next trip to the islands.

AMI Locals staff

Perfect location for a perfect vacation. The house was just as advertised and the trolly and beach were really close. The kids loved playing in the pool and the house was really clean. Highly recommend!

Peter S. - Posted: 5/26/2021

Thank you so much for staying with us Peter. We love to hear that you and your lovely family had an enjoyable vacation while visiting AMI. You chose a great property and we hope that you will allow us to host you once again on your next trip.

AMI Locals staff

We had a great spring break here! The house was a perfect location and had everything we needed. Very short walk to beach access and close to shops as well! Pool was great size for a family and temperature was perfect! Check in super easy and property manage was quick to respond to the few questions we had! We can’t wait to come back!

Maria M. - Posted: 4/9/2021

We are so happy to hear that you had a great stay with us Maria! Our guest are very important to us and you make our day when we read that you have enjoyble your time with us! We hope that you will allow us to host you again on your next trip to the islands.

AMI Locals staff

The property was perfect!! Across the street is beach access, which is perfect for relaxing or just watching a sunset. We rented a car but the trolley pick-up is right across the street. Quiet neighborhood and a nice walk to many shops and restaurants. We loved the heated pool and the home was comfortable and clean. We will book again!

Delana D. - Posted: 12/22/2020

Thank you Delana for your past vacation with us. We're happy to hear you enjoyed the endless views and sunsets as much as we do. You were wonderful guests and we would love to have the chance of hosting you again soon.

AMI Locals staff

Great location and pool was private and nice when not at the beach.

Sarah - Posted: 12/1/2020

Thank you for staying with us, Sarah! We are glad you enjoyed a nice, private vacation here. We hope you'll come back again in the future!

AMI Locals staff

Great place! Super close to the beach & really close to all the popular restaurants & great shops!!
The house had everything we needed & more. My family & I were very pleased with this Airbnb & AMI Locals... they answered all of our questions super fast. The house was very clean and exactly how the pictures portrayed the house on the site. We will definitely come back & will definitely try to book again with AMI Locals!!

Melissa - Posted: 11/20/2020

Awesome place! Clean and tidy! Beautiful location! We’ll be back!

Aaron - Posted: 11/13/2020

Great place!

Gisel - Posted: 9/17/2020

My Island Paradise was the perfect location with a short walk to the beach and quick car ride to the town of Anna Maria. The kitchen is updated and the grill worked great for cooking a nice dinner at home. It was clean, very private and quiet, which is what we wanted especially with COVID.

Verified traveler - Posted: 9/9/2020

Thanks so much for sharing your heartwarming feedback with us! We strive to provide the utmost care for our guests and are delighted to hear your stay was perfect. We look forward to your return.

AMI Locals staff

Perfect for 4 adults and 1 kid. The beach was just around the corner and the pool was great. Will definitely use AMI locals and stay at this location in the future

Emily - Posted: 8/28/2020

Short walk to the beach! It was very clean and we loved having a private pool.

Jennifer R. - Posted: 7/7/2020

Thank you Jennifer. for your stay! We loved being your home away from home while here. Your feedback is much appreciated and we hope to see you on your next adventure to the island.

AMI Locals staff

Literally everything you need with beach, pool, quiet, and fun for a small group!

Philip - Posted: 6/13/2020

Cozy property in quiet neighborhood on corner half block from gulf beach. 3 min walk to beach access point. I made a beautiful beach walk to Bean Point every day which was about a mile and half each way. Condo was just as it looked in the online photos. Living room TV was tricky to work but it was a wonderful place overall. Just an excellent spot. It was myself, son and daughter and they loved it. I would highly recommend this place.

Gregory Scott F. - Posted: 1/15/2020

Thank you for your review Gregory, we appreciate it!

AMI Locals staff

All the comforts of home,Beautiful property and great service!

Walter N. - Posted: 11/11/2019

Thank you so much, Walter! Hope to host you again.

AMI Locals staff

As described

Chris - Posted: 10/26/2019

The property was lovely, loved the pool, close to beach. unfortunately our week had a lot of rain, but the property was so comfortable, we did not mind that much.

debbie w. - Posted: 8/18/2019

Thank you so much for your review. We as so glad you loved your property. We hope to see you next time and let the sun shine!

AMI Locals staff

Beautiful facility. Worth the $.

Verified traveler - Posted: 7/18/2019

We're glad you enjoyed your stay, and look forward to hosting you again :)

AMI Locals staff

Home was very nice and clean. Girls loved the pool and only a very short walk to the beach. Lisa was very helpful and answered any questions quickly!

Aletha M. - Posted: 6/8/2019

We stayed as a family of four with a ten month old and loved the home and location! The home is beautifully decorated just as pictured, and very clean! We rented a crib from a local baby rental store for our daughter, and enjoyed the private pool to allow her to ease into her first swimming experiences. The location is less than 1 block from the beach and is on the north side of town which has Bean Point, the best place to watch sunsets on the island. The Waterfront and Ginny’s restaurants were our favorites. We also fished at Rod and Reel Pier. Lisa, the property manager, was kind and thoughtful in all communication and we gratefully appreciated our stay and the family memories made! Thank you, Mandi & family

Mandi W. - Posted: 5/16/2019

After a stressful year for us and my elderly parents, we had an excellent, restful stay in this adorable cottage. Sunset walks every evening. Dinners out to all the great restaurants and shopping in cute boutiques. Loved our stay and will definitely come back to AMI.

Luana B. - Posted: 5/10/2019

House and pool were perfect for our family of five. Very clean and great location with a short walk to the beach. Would definitely recommend.

Jeff S. - Posted: 3/27/2019

Thx

Dale C. - Posted: 3/10/2019

Thanks for your review and we appreciate it! We are happy to host you again and you were a wonderful guest.

AMI Locals staff

Amazing location...close to Beach and shops. Great neighbourhood. Our family rang in 2019 on the Island and can't say enough about it. Have wanted to return since the moment we left. Lisa Coba and her team at AMI locals were incredible whenever we needed anything. Will most certainly be back again....highly recommended by the "Dunlops" of Muskoka Ontario.

shelly d. - Posted: 1/10/2019

My family stayed at this property in May for our first time in AMI. We absolutely loved it. Even though we had a rainy week we still had a blast: the house was so clean and the pool area was beautiful. Ashley was so helpful throughout our stay. To end the great trip I even got engaged on the beach! Can’t wait to stay again

Anna S. - Posted: 9/17/2018

Thanks so much, Anna! I'm so happy you enjoyed your stay at My Island Paradise and what a wonderful way to remember it with an engagement! :) Congratulations again to you and your fiance. I look forward to hosting you again soon! -Ashley

AMI Locals staff

Great location, literally a block from the beach! Perfect size for our family of 5! Tastefully furnished and thoughtfully stocked with a little welcome pack. Anna Maria Island is a truly special place and we hope to return soon!

Mellissa B. - Posted: 6/26/2018

Thank you, Mellissa! I appreciate your review, and am so glad this beach villa worked well for your family! Keep us in mind when you're ready to plan your next trip. -Ashley

AMI Locals staff

Cute little bungalow on Anna Maria. Great value. We all loved the private pool!

Verified traveler - Posted: 2/13/2018